Traditional retained search firms charge about one-third of the hire's first-year compensation, so the fee rises when the pay package rises. A flat-fee retained search fixes the fee before the search starts, so the firm earns the same whatever the final offer. For AI leadership roles, where pay varies widely (FY2025 Chief AI Officer filings ranged from $105,269 to $400,000 in base wage), that removes a conflict of interest and makes the budget predictable.
Free AI leadership role brief
Before you write a job description, get a one-page brief on your role after a 30-minute call: scope, reporting line, a pay range from public filings, and where the candidates are.
Get my role brief →How do percentage search fees work?
Retained firms are paid a share of the hire's first-year pay. Heidrick & Struggles describes the fee in its Form 10-K as approximately one-third of estimated first-year compensation. On base wage alone, that is about $35,090 for the lowest FY2025 Chief AI Officer filing ($105,269) and about $133,333 for the highest ($400,000). Bonus and equity push the fee higher.
Why does this matter more for AI leadership searches?
Because AI leadership pay is not settled. A CFO search has well-known benchmarks and a narrow range. AI leadership pay is shaped by competing offers from technology companies, equity expectations that may not fit your structure, and a market that can move during the search. The spread in public filings shows it: AI leadership titles in FY2025 Department of Labor filings had a median offered base wage of $200,000, but the Chief AI Officer filings alone ran from $105,269 to $400,000 (see the table).
Under a percentage fee, the firm has no financial reason to help you manage that. If a competing offer lifts the candidate's base by $30,000, the fee rises by about $10,000. You pay more for the candidate and more for the search.
How does a flat-fee retained search work?
The fee is agreed before the search starts and doesn't change with the final offer. It reflects the work of the search (research, assessment, candidate engagement, closing) rather than the size of the package. At Talent Echo the fee is fixed before the search begins and paid in thirds.
What do you give up with a flat fee?
Nothing in the work itself. Sourcing, assessment, references and closing support are the same. What decides quality is the firm's method, network and knowledge of the AI leadership market, not how the fee is calculated.
When does a flat fee make the most difference?
In three situations: high-pay searches, where a percentage fee gets large; several AI leadership searches at once, where percentage fees compound; and mid-market or mission-driven organizations, where the search budget is tight. Flat fee vs percentage: the arithmetic works through examples.
Frequently asked questions
How much do executive search firms charge?
Traditional retained firms charge about one-third of the hire's first-year compensation; Heidrick & Struggles describes its fee that way in its Form 10-K. On a $200,000 base wage, the FY2025 median offered for AI leadership roles, that is about $66,700 before bonus and equity are counted.
What is a flat-fee retained search?
A retained search where the fee is agreed before the search starts and doesn't change with the hire's final pay. The work is the same as a percentage search; only the fee calculation differs.
Is a flat-fee search lower quality?
No. Quality depends on the firm's method, network and knowledge of the market. The fee structure only changes how the firm is paid, and removes its incentive to push pay up.
Written by Husani Bastien with research and drafting help from AI tools. Every figure was checked against the sources below.
Sources
- Heidrick & Struggles, Form 10-K (retained search fee of about one-third of estimated first-year compensation).
- Talent Echo, What US Employers Offer AI Leaders: FY2025 Wage Filings (US Department of Labor LCA disclosure data).