Retained vs Contingency Executive Search: How They Differ and Which to Use

Two ways to pay a search firm, and why the payment model changes how the search is run.

6 min read
Short answer

A retained search firm is paid in stages as the search progresses, works exclusively on your role and runs a full process: scoping, market mapping, assessment and references. A contingency recruiter is paid only if you hire their candidate, usually works without exclusivity and competes on speed. Retained search is generally used for senior roles such as a Chief AI Officer, and large retained firms typically charge about one-third of the hire's estimated first-year compensation.

Free AI leadership role brief

Before you write a job description, get a one-page brief on your role after a 30-minute call: scope, reporting line, a pay range from public filings, and where the candidates are.

Get my role brief →

How is each model paid?

Retained: the fee is paid in instalments, usually a first payment at the start and the rest at milestones. Heidrick & Struggles, one of the largest retained firms, describes its fee as typically about one-third of the estimated first-year compensation of the position.

Contingency: nothing is paid unless you hire a candidate the recruiter presented. The fee is due at the hire.

How does the work differ?

Because a retained firm is paid to run the search, it can do the slow work: agreeing the role and the success measures, mapping the whole market including people who are not looking, assessing candidates in depth and checking references. Because a contingency recruiter is paid only on a hire, often in competition with other recruiters, the incentive is to put forward available candidates quickly. That suits roles with many candidates. It suits a first Chief AI Officer much less, where the best candidates are usually employed and need to be approached.

Which is right for a senior AI role?

Retained search fits roles that are senior, new to the organization, hard to define, or confidential: a first Chief AI Officer, a Head of AI Governance, or an AI-literate board member. Contingency can work for well-defined roles below the executive level where many qualified people are actively looking.

What is wrong with a percentage fee?

When the fee is a share of the hire's compensation, the firm earns more when the package is bigger, which is the opposite of the client's interest in the negotiation. A flat fee removes that conflict: the cost is agreed before the search starts and does not move with the offer. Talent Echo runs retained searches on a flat fee, agreed on a scoping call and paid in thirds at engagement, shortlist and placement. Our comparison of flat-fee and percentage search works through the arithmetic.

What should you ask any search firm?

Who will run the search day to day? How many searches does that person carry? How will you find candidates who are not looking? What happens if the hire leaves early? What is the total fee, and does it change with the offer? How to choose an AI executive search firm covers the rest.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between retained and contingency search?

A retained firm is paid in stages, works exclusively and runs a full search. A contingency recruiter is paid only if you hire their candidate, usually without exclusivity.

How much does retained executive search cost?

Large retained firms typically charge about one-third of the hire's estimated first-year compensation; Heidrick and Struggles describes its fee that way. Flat-fee retained firms agree a fixed fee before the search starts.

Is retained search worth it for a Chief AI Officer?

Usually. The best candidates are employed and need to be approached, the role is often new and needs scoping, and the hire is senior enough that a full assessment and reference process pays for itself.

Written by Mariya with research and drafting help from AI tools. Every figure was checked against the sources below.

Sources

Share this article LinkedIn X Email Copy Link
← All Articles Get a free role brief →

Ready to talk about who should lead your AI?

Flat-fee retained search. No percentage of compensation. Aligned with your interests.

Get a free role brief